Semua Tentang Aku: Jangan Nilai Film Dari Perspektif Agama Saja

Jangan Nilai Film Dari Perspektif Agama Saja

Kalangan ulama berbeda pendapat tentang film 2012. Kalau Ketua MUI Kabupaten Malang, Mahmud Zubaidi, menyebut film itu menyesatkan masyarakat, Ketua PW NU Jatim KH Mutawakkil Alallah menilai film tak bisa hanya dilihat dari perspektif agama saja.

Mahmud Zubaidi mengaku belum melihat film itu. ”Namun bila benar filmnya berisi keyakinan kiamat terjadi pada 2012, itu sudah salah. Film yang salah sama sekali tidak mendidik masyarakat," ujar Mahmud saat dihubungi di Malang, Selasa (17/11).

Dia menambahkan, imbauan tidak melihat film ini lantaran isi film yang sangat salah. Kesalahan pada film ini adalah melangkahi kekuasaan Tuhan, yakni berani menyatakan kapan terjadinya kiamat itu. Pasalnya, sambung Mahmud, menurut ajaran Islam, hari kiamat tidak dapat dipastikan kapan terjadinya karena itu menjadi kuasa Allah SWT.

Seharusnya, lanjut dia, Badan Sensor Film (BSF) lebih teliti mengamati film yang akan ditayangkan di bioskop. Pendapat lain disampaikan KH Mutawakkil Alallah. Dia mengaku menjadwalkan menonton film itu Kamis depan.

"Saya mau komentar banyak kalau sudah melihat filmnya. Saya mau lihat Kamis nanti," ujar Mutawakkil dihubungi melalui telepon Kamis siang.

Namun Mutawakkil menegaskan, sebuah film tidak bisa hanya dilihat dari perspektif agama. Pengasuh Ponpes Zainul Hasan Genggong, Pajarakan, Probolinggo itu mengatakan, dirinya yakin pembuat film tidak bermaksud meramalkan kiamat. "Itu kan film fiktif yang sifatnya menghibur. Makanya saya ingin lihat sendiri sebelum memberi komentar," ujarnya.

Soal kiamat, kiai penggemar bulutangkis ini menegaskan, tidak ada seorang pun yang bisa meramalkan kiamat. "Apalagi menyebutkan terjadi tahun 2012. Kiamat itu sesuatu yang gaib dan hanya Allah saja yang tahun kapan datangnya," ujarnya.

Meski belum melihat, Mutawakkil sudah bisa menebak jalan ceritanya tidak mirip di Alquran. "Di Alquran, gambaran kiamat jauh lebih dahsyat. Bagaimana mau menggambarkan langit mau runtuh, bumi dibolak-balik dan sebagainya," ujarnya.

Terlepas dari kontroversi film, Mutawakkil mengatakan kiamat itu merupakan proses bagi setiap manusia apakah menuju surga atau neraka. "Proses kiamat kan mulai bangkit dari kubur hingga ditentukan apakah dia mau masuk neraka atau surga," ujarnya.

Ia juga mengatakan kiamat bisa juga dimulai saat seseorang meninggal. “Seperti sabda Rasul, kiamat itu ketika seseorang ditinggakan ajal,” ujarnya.

Dimintai pendapatnya soal haram atau halal, Mutawakkil mengaku tak mau seperti Majelis Ulama Indonesia. “Nggak usah seperti MUI lah,” ujarnya.

Di luar perdebatan ini, film yang dibintangi John Cusack, Danny Glover dan Chiwetel Ejiofor, yang bercerita hancurnya Planet Bumi pada tahun 2012 sesuai ramalan Suku Maya di Amerika Selatan telah meraup keuntungan besar karena menjadi box office begitu ditayangkan mulai Jumat.

Dalam tiga hari penayangan, 65 juta dollar AS dikumpulkan produser. Itu hanya di Amerika Serikat. Di seluruh di dunia, film 2012 diperkirakan menghasilkan 225 juta dollar AS. Dibanding dengan ongkos produksi 200 juta dollar, film ini untung besar baru dalam empat hari hanya dalam waktu 4 hari.

Do not Value Films From Only Religious Perspective

Disagreement among scholars about the film in 2012. If the MUI Chairman of Malang Regency, Mahmoud Zubaidi, called the film is misleading the public, the Chairman of East Java NU PW KH Mutawakkil Alallah rate movies could only be seen from a religious perspective alone.

Mahmoud Zubaidi admitted it had not seen the film. "But if the right end of the film contains a conviction occurred in 2012, it was wrong. The wrong film did not educate people, "Mahmud said, when contacted in Kuching, Tuesday (17/11).

He added that an appeal does not see this movie because the content is very wrong movie.Error in this film is stepping power of God, the brave declared that when the Hour. The reason, continued Mahmud, according to the teachings of Islam, the Day of Resurrection can not be certain when it happened because it was the power of Allah SWT.

It should, he added, Film Censorship Board (BSF) is more closely watched film will be shown in theaters. Other opinions presented Alallah KH Mutawakkil. He claimed that the movie scheduled next Thursday.

"I want to comment a lot when I saw the movie. I want to see next Thursday," said Mutawakkil be reached by phone Thursday afternoon.

Mutawakkil Yet asserted, a film can not only be seen from a religious perspective. Caregiver Ponpes Genggong Zainul Hasan, Pajarakan, Probolinggo said, he was sure the film makers did not intend to predict doom. "It's a fictional movie character entertaining.'s Why I wanted to see for yourself before making the comment," he said.

Question Hour, kiai confirmed badminton fans, no one can foretell doom. "After mentioning happened in 2012. Resurrection is something unseen and only God alone is the year when the arrival," he said.

Though not seen, Mutawakkil was able to guess the plot did not like the Koran. "In the Koran, the picture is much more powerful end. How would describe the sky is falling, the earth be inverted and so forth," he said.

Apart from the controversy the film, said the Resurrection Mutawakkil was a process for every human being whether to heaven or hell. "The right end began to rise from the grave to be determined whether he would go to hell or heaven," he said.

He also said the end may also be started when someone dies. "As word of the Apostle, Resurrection ditinggakan that when a person dying," he said.

Polled about haram or halal, Mutawakkil did not want to admit as Indonesian Ulema Council. "I do not have to like the MUI is," he said.

Beyond this debate, the film starring John Cusack, Danny Glover and Chiwetel Ejiofor, who tells the destruction of planet Earth in the year 2012 according to forecasts Maya in South America has made a fortune as a box office that aired from Friday.

Within three days of delivery, U.S. $ 65 million collected producers. It is only in the United States. Throughout the world, the film is estimated to produce 2012 U.S. $ 225 million.Production costs compared with 200 million dollars, this film is a new fortune in four days in just 4 days.